Key witness dodges testifying, delaying fatal dump truck crash trial
The trial of Milton Urgiles, accused of criminal negligence leading to the death of one of his workers in 2020, resumed Friday in a Barrie courtroom with the Crown alleging that a key witness was "holding her evidence hostage."
For weeks, the court has tried and failed to serve Janeth Zambrano with a subpoena to testify at the trial of her common-law spouse.
"It is clearly evident that Ms. Zambrano has gone to great lengths to evade service," the Crown stated.
- Download the CTV News app free to get local alerts on your device
- Get the latest local updates sent to your email inbox
The court heard Zambrano, who owns the trucking company that employs Urgiles as its supervisor, provided the dump truck involved in the crash on Sept. 22, 2020, that resulted in the death of 53-year-old driver Denis Garant along the Adjala-Tecumseth Townline near Alliston.
The Crown believes Zambrano holds crucial evidence that would be "detrimental to the court's truth-seeking function," including procedures and safety policies relating to the vehicles.
On Tuesday, Justice Mary Vallee ordered the issuance of a material witness warrant for the arrest of Zambrano after police also admitted serving the woman with a court subpoena for the preliminary hearing proved challenging.
Police arrested Urgiles months after the deadly crash, alleging a mechanical defect caused the company's dump truck to lose control, crash into a ditch and collide with a tree claiming the life of Garant.
A dump truck crashed into a tree on Adjala-Tecumseth Townline near Alliston, Ont., on Sept. 22, 2020.
The Crown said text messages Garant sent to Urgiles noting his concerns about the truck's steering the night before the collision went unanswered and that the supervisor put Garant back behind the wheel of the dump truck the following day.
Zambrano's avoidance of the courtroom left the Crown to seek a hearsay application in her absence and request preliminary hearing testimony to also be heard at the trial.
Shopping Trends
The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at CTV News. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING
BREAKING Trudeau promoting backbenchers in sizable cabinet shuffle coming Friday: sources
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is planning a sizable cabinet shuffle on Friday, and it's shaping up to see several Liberal backbenchers promoted to ministerial posts, sources confirm to CTV News.
Prime minister's team blindsided by Freeland's resignation: source
The first time anyone in the senior ranks of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's office got any indication Chrystia Freeland was about to resign from cabinet was just two hours before she made the announcement on social media, a senior government source tells CTV News.
'Tragic and sudden loss': Toronto police ID officer who died after suspected medical episode while on duty
A police officer who died after having a suspected medical episode on duty was executing a search warrant in connection with an ongoing robbery investigation in North York, Toronto police confirmed Thursday.
Ontario town seeks judicial review after being fined $15K for refusing to observe Pride Month
An Ontario community fined $15,000 for not celebrating Pride Month is asking a judge to review the decision.
The Royal Family spreads holiday cheer with new Christmas cards
The Royal Family is spreading holiday cheer with newly released Christmas cards.
Who received the longest jail terms in the Gisele Pelicot rape trial?
A French court found all 51 defendants guilty on Thursday in a mass rape case including Dominique Pelicot, who repeatedly drugged his then wife, Gisele, and allowed dozens of strangers into the family home to rape her.
Youth support worker found guilty of sexually assaulting B.C. boy in government care
A former youth support worker has been convicted of sexually assaulting a 14-year-old boy in B.C. government care – an incident that followed months of secret hangouts and shirtless massages that were in clear violation of his employer's policies.
W5 Investigates
W5 Investigates Provinces look to Saskatchewan on how to collect millions more for victims of crime
A W5 investigation showed how convicted criminals ordered to pay restitution struggled to do so, and how just $7 million of more than $250 million had been claimed. While many provinces struggle to keep track, Saskatchewan is leading the way in making sure victims get their money.
'Theodore Too' refloated after partial sinking in St. Catharines
The life-size replica of Theodore Tugboat, Theodore TOO, is upright again after suffering a partial sinking Tuesday.
Kitchener
-
Ontario launches review into pricey Italy trip by Catholic school board trustees
Ontario has appointed a reviewer to look into expenses at the Brant Haldimand Norfolk Catholic District School Board after four trustees spent $45,000 on a trip to Italy to buy $100,000 worth of art.
-
Frustration builds after third break-in this year at charity thrift store
Staff at Retail Therapy KW Thrift & Consign say they feel helpless after their store was broken into for the third time this year.
-
Inquest rules Fergus man's death a homicide after he was shot by police
A jury has ruled that a Fergus man's death in 2021 was a homicide.
London
-
33 teaching positions to be eliminated by the Thames Valley District School Board
"It's precarious work.” Occasional teachers likely to be affected most by staffing cuts.
-
Community in mourning after boy struck by vehicle while getting off school bus dies
The Lambeth and area community is in mourning after learning a young boy passed away after being struck by a vehicle while getting off his school bus Monday afternoon.
-
College faculty across Ontario take step towards labour disruption in January
Students at Ontario colleges enter their winter break under a cloud of uncertainty after the union representing faculty members raised the stakes at the bargaining table.
Windsor
-
'It's a crisis situation': Food bank usage tops list of 2024 Food Stories in Canada as holiday hampers get handed out in Windsor
Local dignitaries and donors joined Unemployed Help Centre (UHC) staff Thursday morning in distributing 250 Christmas food hampers to preregistered food bank clients at the UHC – Hub of Opportunities.
-
Recognize them? Vehicle theft suspects sought in west Windsor
Windsor police are looking for two suspects after a vehicle was reported stolen outside an apartment building in the west end.
-
St. Clair College offers students 'a million ways to create' with STEM kit donation
St. Clair College’s Research and Innovation team is donating 122 LEGO robotics kits and 22 Apple iPads to students across Windsor-Essex, Chatham-Kent, and Lambton-Kent.
Northern Ontario
-
Most properties in massive northern Ont. real estate insolvency sold
The 323 most profitable of 407 properties in northern Ontario owned by insolvent real estate companies have been sold.
-
Overflowing septic tanks lead to $46K in fines for trailer park owner in Chapleau, Ont.
Issues including failing and overflowing septic tanks led to fines and surcharges totalling more than $57,00 for the owner of a mobile home park in Chapleau.
-
North Bay woman accused of throwing coffee, spitting on victim
A woman who had been banned from a North Bay business is charged with assault with a weapon after allegedly returning and causing a scene.
Sault Ste. Marie
-
Most properties in massive northern Ont. real estate insolvency sold
The 323 most profitable of 407 properties in northern Ontario owned by insolvent real estate companies have been sold.
-
Workforce survey highlights challenges faced by community, social services
The results of a survey about the challenges faced by community and social services conducted by Workforce Planning for Sudbury & Manitoulin are in.
-
'There's just no rhyme or reason': Sault gun shop owners frustrated by additions to gun ban
The federal government’s recent expansion of its gun buy-back program has frustrated firearm owners and sellers in the Sault Ste. Marie area.
Ottawa
-
OPP charge three former hospital employees with patient privacy breach after unrelated incidents
Three former hospital employees have been charged following investigations into unrelated alleged breach of patient privacy incidents that took place over the course of last year in different parts of the province, according to the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP).
-
What to know about getting packages shipped in time for Christmas
Canada Post is ramping up its operations following a month-long strike but there's no guarantee mail or packages will be delivered by Christmas because of the backlog.
-
Christmas shoppers prioritizing savings this year
The countdown is on for Christmas with the big day now less than a week away. It means that stores are busy with last-minute shoppers who are trying to get everything done.
Toronto
-
'Tragic and sudden loss': Toronto police ID officer who died after suspected medical episode while on duty
A police officer who died after having a suspected medical episode on duty was executing a search warrant in connection with an ongoing robbery investigation in North York, Toronto police confirmed Thursday.
-
Man, 34, dies in drive-by shooting in Scarborough Village
A 34-year-old man has died in an overnight drive-by shooting in Scarborough Village, police say.
-
Toronto under winter weather travel advisory, snow could affect Friday morning commute
A winter weather travel advisory is in effect for the Greater Toronto Area (GTA), warning of heavy snow that could affect Friday morning’s commute.
Montreal
-
Quebec professor charged for stealing scholarship money intended for foreign students
Quebec anticorruption police have arrested a former university professor for allegedly defrauding and extorting foreign students.
-
Closure of West Island clinic threatens access to health care for thousands
Statcare Emergency Clinic in Pointe-Claire is facing closure, putting thousands of patients at risk of losing access to health care.
-
Longueuil community steps up to replenish shelves after massive meat theft at food bank
In mid-November, a Longueuil food bank was robbed of $10,000 worth of frozen meat, but the community pulled through an helped replenish the supplies.
Atlantic
-
Snowfall warnings issued ahead of Friday night nor'easter in Maritimes
A developing storm moving northward just off the U.S. eastern seaboard looks likely to bring a heavy early winter snowfall to much of Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island, and the southeastern corner of New Brunswick.
-
'Theodore Too' refloated after partial sinking in St. Catharines
The life-size replica of Theodore Tugboat, Theodore TOO, is upright again after suffering a partial sinking Tuesday.
-
Police investigate robberies in Halifax and Dartmouth, N.S.
Halifax Regional Police (HRP) are investigating a robbery at a gas station Wednesday night.
Winnipeg
-
Birchwood Terrace tenant thrilled and anxious to move home
There is still a security fence around the Birchwood Terrace apartment building on Portage Avenue, but displaced tenants like Debby Ross can finally start going back.
-
Former Winnipeg teacher faces new charges involving underage girls
A former Winnipeg teacher who had been previously charged with voyeurism, sexual assault, and accessing child pornography is facing more charges related to a number of incidents throughout 2024.
-
Manitoba man wins $40M Lotto Max jackpot
A Manitoba man has won one of the top five largest lottery jackpots in Manitoba history.
Calgary
-
Alberta government's Green Line report raises feasibility questions: Gondek
A report on the Alberta government's proposed alignment for Calgary's Green Line light-rail transit project raises questions about the feasibility of an above-ground track, says Mayor Jyoti Gondek.
-
Measles exposure possible in Calgary after lab-confirmed case: AHS
Alberta Health Services (AHS) has issued a warning about multiple possible measles exposures around Calgary after a person with a confirmed case was out in public while infectious.
-
Alberta's Smith disappointed federal pension plan report offers no estimate of share
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith says the province has heard back from Canada’s chief actuary on its bid to leave the Canada Pension Plan but says there's no estimate on how much the province should get.
Edmonton
-
Inmate dead after assault at the Edmonton Remand Centre: police
The Edmonton Police Service is investigating the death of an inmate at the Edmonton Remand Centre.
-
Cold and flu season not hitting as many Albertans as last year
Cold and flu season is in full swing, but cases of influenza, respiratory syncytial virus and COVID-19 appear to be down across the province compared to last year.
-
Arvidsson to return to Oilers lineup vs. Bruins after five-week absence
A key free-agent acquisition will be back in the Edmonton Oilers' lineup on Thursday after missing more than a month of National Hockey League action due to injury.
Regina
-
Appeal dismissed in Sask. 'thumbs up' emoji case
An appeal to a legal case that made international headlines has been dismissed by Saskatchewan's highest court.
-
Manslaughter charge laid in death on Little Black Bear First Nation
A 20-year-old woman is facing a manslaughter charge in relation to a suspicious death on Little Black Bear First Nation.
-
RPS add mobile drug testing unit in time for holidays
The Regina Police Service (RPS) has added a Mobile Testing Unit (MTU) to its capabilities – as the service works to crack down on impaired drivers.
Saskatoon
-
How do THC gummies impact driving? Sask. researchers use simulator to find out
Researchers at the University of Saskatchewan are conducting a study to learn how THC edibles impact driving performance.
-
Sask. man tries to 'opt out' of fentanyl trafficking trial as 'sovereign individual'
A Saskatchewan man has tried to convince a King’s Bench judge of his right to opt out of legal proceedings as a “natural, freeborn, sovereign individual.”
-
Appeal dismissed in Sask. 'thumbs up' emoji case
An appeal to a legal case that made international headlines has been dismissed by Saskatchewan's highest court.
Vancouver
-
Woman hospitalized, man arrested after serious assault in Delta home
Police were called to a home in Delta Thursday afternoon for reports of a serious assault.
-
B.C. police watchdog investigating death of Central Saanich officer
British Columbia's police oversight agency is investigating the death of a Central Saanich police sergeant who had been charged with sexual assault and breach of trust hours before he was found dead on Wednesday.
-
Last weekend before Christmas brings lots of festive events in Metro Vancouver
Whether you're looking to finish some last-minute shopping or just soak in the spirit of the season, there are lots of things to do in Metro Vancouver on the final weekend before Christmas. Here are some options.
Vancouver Island
-
B.C. police watchdog investigating death of Central Saanich officer
British Columbia's police oversight agency is investigating the death of a Central Saanich police sergeant who had been charged with sexual assault and breach of trust hours before he was found dead on Wednesday.
-
Youth support worker found guilty of sexually assaulting B.C. boy in government care
A former youth support worker has been convicted of sexually assaulting a 14-year-old boy in B.C. government care – an incident that followed months of secret hangouts and shirtless massages that were in clear violation of his employer's policies.
-
B.C. repeals public drug use law after challenge and Ottawa's similar changes
The British Columbia government has repealed a law it passed last year to restrict drug use in some public areas because successful court challenges prevented it from being brought into force.
