Accusations of blame-shifting emerge in trial over fatal dump truck crash near Alliston
The man charged with criminal negligence causing death in a dump truck crash near Alliston three years ago took the stand in a Barrie courtroom Thursday and was grilled by the Crown about his involvement.
While professing his innocence in connection to the deadly crash on Sept. 22, 2020, along the Adjala-Tosorontio-New Tecumseth Townline, Milton Urgiles responded to the Crown's continuous questions about his involvement with "I don't remember" or "I can't remember."
Still, the Crown hammered away at Urgiles for more than five hours, accusing him of shifting the blame for the crash on 53-year-old Denis Garant, who was behind the wheel of the dump truck the day it blew its front left tire and crashed into a ditch; killing him instantly.
The Crown argued Urgiles was trying to "remove fault from himself and place it squarely on Mr. Garant."
- Download the CTV News app free to get local alerts on your device
- Get the latest local updates sent to your email inbox
The Crown asked Urgiles about his several safety infractions and the loss of his commercial vehicle operator's registration in 2014 after racking up more than $7,000 in unpaid fines.
The 46-year-old man from Toronto told the court he couldn't remember how he'd dealt with the fine or when he had owned the 2006 Freightliner Garant was driving that day.
The Crown referenced Urgiles' earlier testimony, where he said he trained Garant over three or four days and Garant was making mistakes driving the dump truck. Urgiles noted Garant made several errors in completing turns and operating the truck's lift.
He testified he warned Garant to be careful.
The court heard the dump truck was supplied by Urgiles and the company he worked for - EcuaCan Excavating, which is owned by Urgiles' spouse, Janeth Zambrano, who, despite a court order, has evaded testifying against her longtime partner.
"There is a scheme at play here, and it cost someone's life," the Crown said.
The trial got underway in late September and picked up again last month when Urgiles testified he received a text from Garant the night before the crash in which Garant expressed concerns over the dump truck's steering.
Urgiles testified he later checked the truck's steering for any defects that night and told the court he found nothing wrong.
"I went to check the truck, not to fix it. To make sure it was okay. To make sure it was safe to drive on the street," he testified.
The trial is scheduled to resume in mid-December.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6959223.1720655672!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
NEW Burial plots and cottages: How to navigate capital gains tax changes on properties you may not have thought about
Here are some of the lesser-known ways the capital gains tax might apply to you, and expert tips for navigating the tax.
DEVELOPING Canada set to provide details on defence funding timeline as NATO summit wraps up
Canada is expected to provide more details about its plan to meet defence spending targets in an effort to quell concerns that have dogged the prime minister during this week's NATO summit in Washington, D.C.
opinion Biden's debate debacle levels playing field with Trump
In one week, Donald Trump will officially accept his party’s nomination, becoming the standard-bearer for the GOP in November. A recent Supreme Court immunity ruling combined with a failed debate performance by President Joe Biden has seen the Republican challenger’s fortunes rise exponentially.
Woman swept to sea while swimming at a Japanese beach is rescued 37 hours later and 50 miles away
A Chinese woman who was swept out to sea while swimming at a Japanese beach was rescued 37 hours later after drifting in a swimming ring more than 80 kilometres (50 miles) in the Pacific Ocean, officials said Thursday.
His brother was found dead, his mother was arrested before this baby was found crawling by a highway
A Louisiana sheriff says a one-year-old 'miracle baby' survived two days of sometimes stormy weather before a truck driver spotted him crawling along a roadside the day after his four-year-old brother was found dead and his mother was arrested in Mississippi.
Interest rate cut hasn't led to rush of homebuyer demand yet: Royal LePage data
Despite expectations of lower interest rates prompting homebuyers to leave the sidelines, a new report says the Bank of Canada's quarter-point cut to its key interest rate last month did not lead to a rush in demand.
Ellen DeGeneres is 'done' after her Netflix special
Ellen DeGeneres has reportedly said she's ready to tap out of performing. The former daytime talk show host let that be known during a recent standup show at the Luther Burbank Center for the Arts in Santa Rosa, California.
Costco to increase annual membership fee to $65 this September
Costco is increasing its annual membership fees in Canada and the U.S. this fall to $65.
Poilievre to make first in-person speech at Assembly of First Nations
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre is expected to make his first in-person address at the Assembly of First Nations today.