McKee challenges life sentence as ‘cruel and unusual punishment’
A 33-year-old man convicted of first-degree murder in the 2019 stabbing death of his father inside their Penetanguishene home wants his life sentence reduced.
Brad McKee, who has been behind bars for five and a half years since the night he killed his father, Bill, argues his mandatory minimum life sentence with no chance of parole for 25 years violates his rights under Section 12 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Bill McKee is pictured in this undated photo. (Supplied)Found guilty by a jury of first-degree murder in 2022, McKee is challenging his sentence is cruel and unusual punishment.
His lawyers, Nathan Gorham and Breana Vandebeek, told the court during submissions in a Barrie courtroom that McKee’s mental disorder affected his moral culpability when he stabbed his father in the neck and killed him on February 11, 2019.
The defence says McKee’s distorted perception of reality, including paranoid delusions about doctors also conspiring against him, hurt his defence in a trial in 2022 when McKee told his lawyer at the time, Mary Cremer, not to call one of the doctors to testify that McKee may have been in a state of psychosis at the time of the killing.
“The evidence paints a crystal clear, undeniable, overwhelming picture of a mentally-disordered man who is fighting against his defence by telling his lawyer she cannot present an account of events that he gave to the doctor that would give him a defence,” said Gorham.
“If you believe Mr. McKee on the surface, it appears he was suffering psychotic symptoms which in theory could exempt him from criminal responsibility.”
The jury heard McKee, who had struggled for years with his mental health and attempted suicide several times, believed his parents were conspiring against him and controlling his life. He thought he was being spied on and his computer was hacked.
McKee confined his parents to their bedroom on the night of Bill McKee’s murder, and when his father tried to call 911 in his ensuite bathroom, his son killed him and then stabbed himself repeatedly. Brad McKee told first responders to let him die. He was taken to hospital and recovered from the stab wounds.
Crown attorney Dennis Chronopoulos told the court McKee knew exactly what he did the moment he did it.
“The jury agreed with that. The jury found a subjective intent for murder, the highest level of intent in our criminal justice system,” said Chronopoulos.
The Crown wants Justice Vanessa Christie to uphold McKee’s first-degree murder conviction and life sentence, saying it should be up to the Court of Appeal and parole board to ultimately decide McKee’s fate.
“That subjective intent for murder equates to a high moral culpability; the highest moral culpability. You can’t say that someone had the subjective intent for murder and then find that they had low moral culpability; the two don’t match,” said the Crown.
The defence told the court McKee was not in control of his actions when he killed his father and only snapped out of that state when the blood began spurting from his father’s neck.
Justice Christie is scheduled to make her decision in early September
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING Canada expands list of banned firearms to include hundreds of new models and variants
The Canadian government is expanding its list of banned firearms, adding hundreds of additional makes, models and their variants, effective immediately.
LIVE UPDATES Anger, vitriol against health insurers filled social media in the wake of UnitedHealthcare CEO's killing
The masked gunman who stalked and killed UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson used ammunition emblazoned with the words 'deny,' 'defend' and 'depose,' a law enforcement official said Thursday. Here's the latest.
Man wanted for military desertion turns himself in at Canada-U.S. border
A man wanted for deserting the U.S. military 16 years ago was arrested at the border in Buffalo, N.Y. earlier this week.
'At the dawn of a third nuclear age,' senior U.K. commander warns
The head of Britain’s armed forces has warned that the world stands at the cusp of a 'third nuclear age,' defined by multiple simultaneous challenges and weakened safeguards that kept previous threats in check.
These foods will be hit hardest by inflation in 2025, according to AI modelling
The new year won’t bring a resolution to rising food costs, according to a new report that predicts prices to rise as much as five per cent in 2025.
The National Weather Service cancels tsunami warning for the U.S. West Coast after 7.0 earthquake
A 7.0 magnitude earthquake shook a large area of Northern California on Thursday, knocking items of grocery store shelves, sending children scrambling under desks and prompting a brief tsunami warning for 5.3 million people along the U.S. West Coast.
Pete Davidson, Jason Sudeikis and other former 'SNL' cast members reveal how little they got paid
Live from New York, it’s revelations about paydays on 'Saturday Night Live.'
Alleged Alberta Bitcoin extortionist, arsonist arrested
Authorities have arrested Finbar Hughes, a man wanted in connection with alleged plots in Calgary and Edmonton that threatened to burn victims' homes if they did not pay him Bitcoin ransoms.
Patrick Brown says foreign interference did not affect Tory leadership race outcome
Brampton Mayor Patrick Brown said foreign interference did not tip the scales in the Conservative party's last leadership race that installed Pierre Poilievre at the helm.