Trial underway for supervisor charged with criminal negligence in deadly 2020 dump truck crash
Milton Urgiles arrived at the Barrie courthouse Monday, on trial for criminal negligence causing death after the dump truck Denis Garant was driving lost control and crashed into a tree three years ago, on Sept. 22, 2020, near Alliston, Ont.
Police charged the 46-year-old man from Toronto eight months after the crash on Adjala-Tecumseth Townline between Concessions 2 and 3, alleging the dump truck 53-year-old Garant was driving had a mechanical defect that caused it to leave the road, crash into a ditch and hit the tree.
On Monday, the Crown alleged that Urgiles was Garant's supervisor at the time of the deadly collision and ignored concerned text messages from Garant notifying him the truck's steering was cutting in and out the night before the fatal crash.
- Download the CTV News app to get local alerts on your device
- Get the latest local updates sent to your email inbox
The Crown told the court Urgiles never responded to the messages and sent the vehicle out the following morning with Garant behind the wheel.
A retired collision reconstruction expert and forensic mechanic took the stand, testifying he found a failed front left tire with no tread left on its inner half and an exposed steel cord during his investigation of the crash scene.
Denis Garant is pictured in this undated photo. (Source: DeMarco Funeral Home obituary)
The expert told the court the tire should not have been on the road that day because the lack of tread would have made maintaining contact with the roadway difficult.
"You're not getting traction, so it is going to cause trouble steering, and the truck will just slide on the asphalt itself," he said, adding the truck would ultimately shift to the side of the damaged tire, causing it to likely burst from overwhelming heat and pressure.
The defence argued documents obtained by Urgiles and the Toronto trucking company he worked for show the truck Garant had been driving had undergone a safety inspection roughly a month before the crash.
The two-week trial began last week and is scheduled to resume Tuesday.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING
BREAKING Former Bank of Canada Governor Mark Carney to join Liberal Party as special adviser
Former Bank of Canada Governor Mark Carney will be joining the Liberal Party as a special adviser. In an official press release on Monday, the party says Carney will serve as the chair of a leader's task force on economic growth.
Catherine, Princess of Wales, 'doing what I can to stay cancer free' after finishing chemotherapy
Catherine, Princess of Wales, has said she has completed her chemotherapy and is 'doing what I can to stay cancer free,' as she plans to return gradually to public life in the months ahead.
John and Matthew Gaudreau are mourned by the hockey community, family and friends at their funeral
Mourners have begun to arrive for the funeral for John and Matthew Gaudreau at a church in suburban Philadelphia on Monday.
BREAKING
BREAKING 'Peter Nygard is a sexual predator:' Former fashion mogul sentenced to 11 years in prison
Former Canadian fashion mogul Peter Nygard has been sentenced to 11 years in prison. The sentence was handed to Nygard, 83, by Ontario Superior Court Justice Robert Goldstein in Toronto on Monday. Last November, a jury found Nygard guilty of four counts of sexual assault following a six-week trial.
'My path to healing and full recovery is long': Read the full message from Catherine, Princess of Wales
Catherine, Princess of Wales, announced Monday she is 'cancer free,' after completing chemotherapy treatment. Here is her message in full.
Amid threat of Air Canada pilots strike, what should you do if your flight gets cancelled?
Thousands of passengers could be stranded as early as Sunday if Air Canada doesn't reach a deal with its pilots' union. Here's what you can do if labour disruptions affect your flight.
Vietnam storm deaths rise to 64 as flooding sweeps away a bus, causes a bridge to collapse
A bridge collapsed and a bus was swept away by flooding in Vietnam on Monday, raising the death toll in the Southeast Asian country to at least 64 from a typhoon and subsequent heavy rains that also damaged factories in export-focused northern industrial hubs, state media reported.
Hunt widens for man who allegedly threw scalding coffee on baby
A man wanted for allegedly throwing scalding coffee on a baby in an unprovoked attack at a park in the northern Australian state of Queensland is now the subject of an international manhunt.
How did a popular Philippine televangelist land on the FBI's most-wanted list?
The 74-year-old preacher Apollo Carreon Quiboloy and four co-accused surrendered Sunday in his religious stronghold in the south. An expanded U.S. indictment in 2021 charged Quiboloy with having sex with women and underage girls and sex trafficking by force, among other crimes.
Shopping Trends
The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at CTV News. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.
Kitchener
-
Guelph man charged after elderly cyclist dies following hit-and-run
An elderly woman has died after she was struck by a vehicle late last week, police say.
-
Three-vehicle crash near Drayton sends two to hospital
A driver has been charged following a three-vehicle crash in Mapleton Township.
-
Jamal Murray agrees to a 4-year, $208M max contract extension with Denver Nuggets: AP sources
Denver Nuggets star point guard Jamal Murray has agreed to a four-year, $208 million maximum contract extension, a person with knowledge of the deal told The Associated Press on Saturday.
London
-
Fatal crash being investigated in Elgin County
Around 11:05 a.m. on Sept 6, emergency services were called to the intersection of Fingal Line and Mill Road in Southwold Township for a two-vehicle crash.
-
Don't get caught in an online scam for Taylor Swift tickets
London police are warning all Swifties not to get caught up in an online scam for tickets. According to police, there have been about 30 reports of fraud in the area.
-
Alleged impaired driver goes wrong way on Highway 401
A 36-year-old London man is facing charges after police say after several Good Samaritans reported a vehicle travelling the wrong way on the Highway 401 in Chatham-Kent.
Windsor
-
Fire crews investigating blaze at former Windsor school
Windsor fire was on scene of a blaze at a former school on Norman Road Sunday afternoon.
-
Alleged impaired driver goes wrong way on Highway 401
A 36-year-old London man is facing charges after police say after several Good Samaritans reported a vehicle travelling the wrong way on the Highway 401 in Chatham-Kent.
-
Caesars Windsor welcoming back the Tenors
The Tenors are once again bringing their holiday show to Windsor.
Northern Ontario
-
Air Canada prepares to shut down as talks with pilots union near deadlock
Air Canada is finalizing plans to suspend most of its operations, likely beginning Sunday, as talks with the pilot union are nearing an impasse over 'inflexible' wage demands, the country's largest airline said on Monday.
-
Hunt widens for man who allegedly threw scalding coffee on baby
A man wanted for allegedly throwing scalding coffee on a baby in an unprovoked attack at a park in the northern Australian state of Queensland is now the subject of an international manhunt.
-
Does the Manitoulin Island swing bridge need replacing sooner rather than later?
Another politician has added his voice to the call to have the timeline to build a new bridge in Little Current to connect Manitoulin Island to the mainland sped up.
Sault Ste. Marie
-
Northern Ont. woman accused of stealing from elderly man in a wheelchair
A 38-year-old woman from northwestern Ontario has been charged with several offences after a man in his 70s confined to a wheelchair was robbed last weekend.
-
Sudbury police continue to investigate teen's disappearance 11 years later
Wednesday marks 11 years since Sudbury teen Meagan Pilon was reported missing and police are appealing to the public again for information.
-
Musician Dany Laj returns to northern Ont. with his band
A Montreal-based power pop band with strong ties to northern Ontario is kicking off its new tour in North Bay at the end of the month followed by three other northern stops.
Ottawa
-
Federal employees now required to be in the office 3 days a week
As tens of thousands of public servants return to the office for a minimum of three days a week this week, public service unions continue to oppose the federal government's new hybrid work policy.
-
PWHL unveils Ottawa Charge team name and logo
Ottawa's professional women's hockey team will be called the Charge, with a spinning 'O' logo designed to convey a sense of energy and movement.
-
Vehicle crashes into front porch at home in Ottawa's Sandy Hill neighbourhood
A 20-year-old driver is facing several charges, including careless driving, after a vehicle crashed into the front porch of a building on King Edward Avenue in Ottawa.
Toronto
-
BREAKINGBREAKING 'Peter Nygard is a sexual predator:' Former fashion mogul sentenced to 11 years in prison
Former Canadian fashion mogul Peter Nygard has been sentenced to 11 years in prison. The sentence was handed to Nygard, 83, by Ontario Superior Court Justice Robert Goldstein in Toronto on Monday. Last November, a jury found Nygard guilty of four counts of sexual assault following a six-week trial.
-
Ford says Singh is 'just blowing smoke' and won't call early federal election
Ontario Premier Doug Ford says he thinks it’s unlikely national NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh will trigger an early federal election after he tore up the deal keeping Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in power last week.
-
BREAKING
BREAKING Former Bank of Canada Governor Mark Carney to join Liberal Party as special adviser
Former Bank of Canada Governor Mark Carney will be joining the Liberal Party as a special adviser. In an official press release on Monday, the party says Carney will serve as the chair of a leader's task force on economic growth.
Montreal
-
Child, grandfather injured after being hit by car in Montreal's east end
A five-year-old child and his 63-year-old grandfather are in hospital after being hit by a car in Montreal's east end.
-
Legault government heads into fall session after resignation of high-profile minister
As the fall session of Quebec’s legislature kicks off this week, Premier François Legault will have to fend off claims his government is past its best-before date, even as he works to shepherd a pivotal energy bill into law.
-
Unions face uphill battle organizing Amazon warehouses in Canada: experts
Unions trying to organize at Amazon workplaces across Canada are facing a series of hurdles, including legal challenges and alleged anti-union tactics from the e-commerce giant.
Atlantic
-
Elsipogtog First Nation man dead after N.B. RCMP shooting, SiRT investigating
The death of a man after an alleged police shooting in Elsipogtog First Nation, N.B., is under investigation.
-
Maine, U.S., man charged with second-degree murder after day-long manhunt in New Brunswick
A 47-year-old man from Maine, U.S., is facing a second-degree murder charge after police arrested him during a day-long manhunt in the Esgenoôpetitj (Burnt Church) First Nation area of New Brunswick on Friday.
-
Month's worth of rain in parts of N.S. this past weekend; Tropical Storm Francine develops in the Gulf of Mexico
A month's worth of rain fell in some areas of Nova Scotia over the weekend.
Winnipeg
-
Teen passenger charged in hit-and-run that killed cyclist: WPS
A second person has been charged in connection with a fatal hit-and-run that killed a cyclist on Wellington Crescent last June.
-
BREAKING
BREAKING 'Peter Nygard is a sexual predator:' Former fashion mogul sentenced to 11 years in prison
Former Canadian fashion mogul Peter Nygard has been sentenced to 11 years in prison. The sentence was handed to Nygard, 83, by Ontario Superior Court Justice Robert Goldstein in Toronto on Monday. Last November, a jury found Nygard guilty of four counts of sexual assault following a six-week trial.
-
Curler Briane Harris awaiting decision of doping appeal after CAS hearing
A lawyer for Team Kerri Einarson lead Briane Harris said a decision on an appeal of the curler's provisional suspension will likely be released in October by the Court of Arbitration for Sport.
Calgary
-
BREAKINGBREAKING Two Alberta men get 6 1/2-year prison sentences for Coutts protest
A judge has sentenced two Alberta men to 6 1/2 years in prison for their roles in the 2022 border blockade at Coutts, Alta.
-
John and Matthew Gaudreau are mourned by the hockey community, family and friends at their funeral
Mourners have begun to arrive for the funeral for John and Matthew Gaudreau at a church in suburban Philadelphia on Monday.
-
Calgary police seek dash-cam footage after fatal Highfield Road crash
Calgary police are asking anyone who witnessed a deadly crash on Highfield Road this past weekend to come forward.
Edmonton
-
More than half of Albertans struggling with daily expenses
Goodbye, Alberta advantage. Half of the province's residents say they are struggling to keep up with daily expenses amid a cost-of-living crisis.
-
Catherine, Princess of Wales, 'doing what I can to stay cancer free' after finishing chemotherapy
Catherine, Princess of Wales, has said she has completed her chemotherapy and is 'doing what I can to stay cancer free,' as she plans to return gradually to public life in the months ahead.
-
John and Matthew Gaudreau are mourned by the hockey community, family and friends at their funeral
Mourners have begun to arrive for the funeral for John and Matthew Gaudreau at a church in suburban Philadelphia on Monday.
Regina
-
Location for new joint use elementary, high schools in Regina announced
The provincial government and City of Regina announced the location for future joint use elementary and high schools in the city's east end on Monday.
-
Temperature records fall as September heat keeps summer alive in Sask.
Numerous high temperature records fell across Saskatchewan on Sunday as a late summer heat wave lingers in the province.
-
Pedestrian seriously injured after collision with vehicle: Regina police
A pedestrian was taken to hospital with serious injuries after they were struck by a vehicle while crossing a street Sunday morning.
Saskatoon
-
Saskatoon police officers snooped on investigation files they had no right to access: Privacy commissioner
Three Saskatoon police officers were caught snooping on nine people’s private information from investigation records for personal reasons, according to the Saskatchewan privacy commissioner.
-
Saskatchewan's police watchdog investigating after death on Ahtahkakoop Cree Nation
Saskatchewan's Serious Incident Response (SIRT) is investigating after a man died as a result of police action on Ahtahkakoop Cree Nation.
-
Online fundraisers launch for victims after Saskatoon student set on fire
Online fundraisers have been launched to support the victims of an incident that saw a student set on fire at Evan Hardy Collegiate on Thursday.
Vancouver
-
B.C. man serving life sentence for murder dies in prison
A convicted killer who was serving a life sentence for the 1993 murder of a woman in the British Columbia Interior has died in prison.
-
Man charged after 4 youths attacked on Galloping Goose trail in Langford, B.C.
A 32-year-old man is facing eight charges, including assault with a weapon and assault causing bodily harm after, after a group of young people were attacked on a popular pedestrian trail on southern Vancouver Island.
-
Employer considers union plan in week two of Metro Vancouver HandyDART transit strike
Most services for Metro Vancouver's specialized HandyDART transit system remain cancelled for a second week, with the operator saying it will respond to a new proposal from the union representing striking workers on Thursday
Vancouver Island
-
B.C. man serving life sentence for murder dies in prison
A convicted killer who was serving a life sentence for the 1993 murder of a woman in the British Columbia Interior has died in prison.
-
Man charged after 4 youths attacked on Galloping Goose trail in Langford, B.C.
A 32-year-old man is facing eight charges, including assault with a weapon and assault causing bodily harm after, after a group of young people were attacked on a popular pedestrian trail on southern Vancouver Island.
-
Dog mauled to death in B.C. yard after 3 pit bulls jump fence: police
A 12-year-old collie was killed by three pit bulls in the B.C. Interior Sunday morning, according to authorities.
