'No motive, no proof:' Defence argues Barrie man couldn't have killed Katherine Janeiro
Warning: Readers may find some details in this article disturbing or upsetting.
Defence lawyer Mary Cremer sought to persuade the jury during closing submissions on Friday that it would have been impossible for her client to have murdered Katherine Janeiro in 1994.
"It absolutely was not Bruce Ellis," Cremer stated in the courtroom. "There is no motive for Bruce Ellis to kill Katherine Janeiro."
Janeiro's lifeless body was found face down in her bedroom by a neighbour. The court heard the 20-year-old mother had been stabbed multiple times.
The Crown told the court Ellis took Janeiro's life because he was furious she had told his wife she was pregnant with his child and spread rumours he contracted AIDS from an exotic dancer.
But the defence argued the timeline of the murder presented by the Crown simply didn't add up, saying it would have been "impossible" for Ellis to kill Janeiro, ransack the house, clean himself up, and return home before his then-wife found him back in bed.
The defence insisted Ellis had no contact with Janeiro that night, adding the Crown had failed to show any proof linking him to the murder.
"You are all being asked to find Bruce Ellis guilty on the basis of all the evidence," Cremer said, adding, "The evidence just does not add up."
Cremer also pointed out that Ellis' phone number was not saved in Janeiro's phone, suggesting that he wasn't involved in her life at the time of her death.
The defence then shifted attention toward two other individuals, Woody Theakston and Paul Daigle, arguing their actions were consistent with those of guilty individuals.
Cremer said the evidence proved Theakston, a now-deceased biker who Janiero sold drugs for, had a motive to kill her.
A witness testified seeing Theakston and Daigle inside Janeiro's apartment rummaging through drawers and cupboards in the kitchen the night of her death.
Daigle admitted to being in the Dunlop Street apartment but told the court he had nothing to do with the murder.
Cremer further highlighted that Theakston had contradicted himself during police interviews and claimed Daigle's testimony was riddled with lies.
"Paul Daigle lied to all of you because he is assisting Woody in the killing of Katherine Janeiro and is lying to you to this day," Cremer told the jury, pointing the finger again at Theakston, stating the evidence "overwhelmingly shows he had the motive to kill Katherine Janeiro."
Cremer told the jury a witness who said she saw Ellis running across the street with Janeiro's phone, which had been ripped from the apartment wall, was not credible or reliable.
"Whatever it was she saw, it absolutely was not Bruce Ellis," the defence told the jury.
The defence also sought to poke holes in the prosecution's claims Ellis was angry over Janeiro's expensive phone bill, which he was paying.
"People don't kill each other over an unpaid phone bill," Ellis' lawyer stated.
Justice Clyde Smith is expected to instruct the jury on Monday before deliberations.
- Download the CTV News app to get local alerts on your device
- Get the latest local updates sent to your email inbox
With files from CTV's Mike Arsalides
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.7097511.1730732725!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
'The best that we can be': Indigenous judge and TRC chair Murray Sinclair dies at 73
Murray Sinclair, who was born when Indigenous people did not yet have the right to vote, grew up to become one of the most decorated and influential people to work in Indigenous justice and advocacy.
India's Modi, Canada's Trudeau condemn violence at Hindu temple near Toronto
The prime ministers of India and Canada condemned violence that broke out on Sunday at a Hindu temple near Toronto at a time of escalating diplomatic tensions between the two countries.
She was diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes about a year ago. Here's how her condition was reversed
A year ago, Lorraine O'Quinn was coping with stress, chronic illness and Type 2 diabetes. Then she discovered a health program that she says changed her life.
Frustration over Mideast war in America's largest Arab-majority city may push some away from Democrats
As an ongoing part of Omar on the Road: America Decides 2024, CTV National News visited the University of Michigan-Dearborn campus to talk to Arab-American students about why they’re feeling left out of the Democrats’ tent.
3 people arrested after incident during protest at Hindu temple in Brampton, Ont.: Peel police
Peel Regional Police say three people are in custody as they continue to investigate an incident during a demonstration at a Hindu temple in Brampton on Sunday.
Judge rules against Alberta casino, dinner theatre operator
An application to stay a receivership order of Mayfield Investments Ltd., a company that owns multiple businesses in Alberta including the Camrose Resort and Casino, Medicine Hat Lodge and Calgary's Stage West Dinner Theatre, has been denied by the court.
Ikea will pay 6 million euros to East German prisoners forced to build their furniture in landmark move
Furniture giant Ikea has agreed to pay 6 million euros (US$6.5 million) towards a government fund compensating victims of forced labour under Germany's communist dictatorship, in a move campaigners hope will pressure other companies to follow.
Police arrest Netanyahu aide as opponents accuse him of leaking intelligence to thwart Gaza ceasefire and hostage deal
Israeli police have arrested a top aide to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu over allegedly leaking classified information to foreign media.
Candlelight vigil held outside Halifax Walmart where employee was found dead
Hundreds of mourners took part in a candlelight vigil Sunday night for a young woman who was found dead at a Halifax Walmart last month.